Benny Lichtenwalner

What is the difference between a dismissive avoidant and a fearful avoidant ex coming back after a breakup?

By Benny Lichtenwalner, breakup coach & author of How to Get Your Ex Back · Updated 2026-11-03

Short answer: A dismissive avoidant goes cold, stays quiet for months, then resurfaces with one small, low-stakes message. A fearful avoidant reaches out early, then retreats, so the return looks like push-pull. Dismissive exes need long, pressure-free silence. Fearful exes need warm, light contact that never demands more than they offer.

A dismissive avoidant ex comes back slowly and quietly: months of silence, then one small message. A fearful avoidant ex comes back loudly and unevenly: an early reach-out, a warm stretch, then a retreat. Same label, different playbook.

I’m Benny Lichtenwalner, breakup coach and author of How to Get Your Ex Back. I coach both types, and the mistake I see most is treating them the same. Waiting out a dismissive avoidant works. Waiting out a fearful avoidant with the same rigid silence often misses the moments when they are actually reachable.

How do I tell a dismissive avoidant from a fearful avoidant?

Watch the first few weeks. The pattern is clearer than any label.

What you see Dismissive avoidant Fearful avoidant
First weeks after the breakup Calm, distant, busy Hot and cold, emotional swings
Contact during no-contact Almost none Reaches out, often late at night
Talks about the relationship Rarely, and briefly Yes, then disappears
Core fear Losing independence Getting close and being left
Typical first reach-out Month 3 to 6, small and casual Weeks 2 to 8, sometimes heavy
Shape of the return Slow and flat, then steady Push-pull, repeating

If you see both patterns, treat the ex as fearful avoidant. A dismissive ex rarely produces the swings.

What does the psychology of each style look like after a breakup?

A dismissive avoidant treats the emotional weight of a breakup as a threat and suppresses it. They get busy, look fine, and may start dating fast. The feelings are delayed, not absent. I cover the stages in what are the stages of an avoidant breakup.

A fearful avoidant wants closeness and fears it at once. Missing you feels real to them, so they reach out. Then the closeness feels unsafe, so they back off. The breakup doesn’t stop that loop. It keeps running with you at the other end.

How long does each type take to come back?

Dismissive: three to six months to a first real reach-out, sometimes longer. The full reasoning is in how long does it take an avoidant ex to come back and why a dismissive avoidant needs at least three months of no-contact.

Fearful: first contact can come in weeks, but a stable return takes longer, because each warm stretch is followed by a pullback. Expect a few cycles. These are case observations from my coaching, not a clinical study.

How should no-contact and re-entry change for each type?

  1. With a dismissive avoidant, hold the full silence. Don’t send check-ins, don’t react to their social media, and don’t show anxiety. Pressure restarts the clock.
  2. When a dismissive ex finally writes, reply once, lightly, and stop. Let them set the pace.
  3. With a fearful avoidant, don’t treat the silence as sacred. If they reach out, answer warmly and briefly within a day or so.
  4. Don’t match a fearful ex’s heavy message with a long confession. Reflect the feeling in a line and keep the tone easy.
  5. After a warm exchange, wait. The retreat usually comes next, and chasing it makes it longer.
  6. For both, build your own life during the wait. Start with the no-contact rule and the attachment styles guide.

What does this look like in practice?

A composite from clients. One man’s ex went silent for four months. He held it, stayed off her accounts, and got a short, casual text about a show they used to watch. He answered once and let it sit. She wrote again two weeks later. Another client’s ex reached out in week three with a long late-night message, called twice, then vanished for ten days. She kept her replies short and warm, didn’t ask what it meant, and the contact came back on its own, each time a little steadier.

What should I not do?

Related questions

How can I tell if my ex is dismissive avoidant or fearful avoidant?

Look at what happens in the first month. A dismissive avoidant goes quiet and seems fine, often busy and cheerful on social media. A fearful avoidant is hot and cold: a warm message one week, silence the next, sometimes a heavy conversation about the relationship followed by a disappearance.

Which type comes back faster after a breakup?

A fearful avoidant usually makes contact sooner, often within weeks. But contact is not a return. A dismissive avoidant usually takes three to six months to resurface, and when they do the return is more stable because it comes after the suppression has worn off.

Should no-contact be longer for a dismissive avoidant?

Usually yes. A dismissive avoidant needs the long end of the window, around four to six months, because any pressure restarts the deactivation. A fearful avoidant often breaks the silence themselves, so your job is to answer warmly and briefly instead of holding a rigid clock.

Why does my fearful avoidant ex keep disappearing after a good conversation?

The closeness is the trigger. A good conversation makes the relationship feel real again, which feels dangerous to them, so they pull back to calm down. It is usually not a game. Keep the next contact light and don't ask where things stand.

Is it worth waiting for either type to come back?

Only if the relationship was worth having. Push-pull from an ex is not by itself a reason to pursue. If the relationship was destructive, or you'd be re-entering the same cycle, the honest answer is to let it stay ended.

Keep going